About Us

We’re excited to announce that this winter 2023, we’re giving Main Street Pizza Company a complete makeover! Going forward you can enjoy all of your favorite authentic Italian classics & pizza at... “Main Street Italian Eatery”.
We are so proud to have been a part of this incredible community for over 10 years. We take pride in being able to serve our authentic Italian delicacies all the way from Italy right here in beautiful Farmingdale, NY.
Get ready to indulge in your Italian favorites from our scratch kitchen. Everything from Main Street Italian Eatery is made completely from scratch and never frozen. Make your reservations now for a dinner experience that your taste buds will never forget.